Ethical considerations for large interdisciplinary networks

By Evelyn Brister, Erin Shoemaker, Susan M. Wolf and Gillian H. Roehrig.

authors_brister_shoemaker_wolf_roehrig
1. Evelyn Brister (biography)
2. Erin Shoemaker (biography)
3. Susan M. Wolf (biography)
4. Gillian H. Roehrig (biography)

What problems in research ethics arise for research networks that cross disciplines and institutions? How do they differ from the ethical issues affecting individual researchers or society at large? What are the lessons for leaders of large research networks?

Addressing complex, real-world problems requires expertise from multiple disciplines. Large, diverse research teams that address these problems may be organized across multiple universities or other research institutions. The larger scale of this network science creates distinctive ethical responsibilities.

To identify responsibilities that fall on network leaders, it is useful to consider ethical issues at three levels: micro, meso, and macro.

The microlevel primarily focuses on individual investigators and small teams working in a single location.

Read more

Epistemological obstacles to interdisciplinary research

By Evelyn Brister

evelyn-brister
Evelyn Brister (biography)

What causes interdisciplinary collaborations to default to the standard frameworks and methods of a single discipline, leaving collaborators feeling like they aren’t being taken seriously, or that what they’ve brought to the project has been left on the table, ignored and underappreciated?

Sometimes it is miscommunication, but sometimes it is that collaborators disagree. And sometimes disagreements are both fundamental and intractable.

Often, these disagreements can be traced back to different epistemological frameworks. Epistemological frameworks are beliefs about how particular disciplines conceive of what it is they investigate, how to investigate it, what counts as sufficient evidence, and why the knowledge they produce matters.

Read more