Aims and overview of i2S

Integration and Implementation Sciences (i2S): 

Improving research and its impact on complex real-world problems

Aims and overview of i2S

Integration and Implementation Sciences (i2S) is a new discipline providing concepts, methods, processes, theories, frameworks and other tools for conducting research that aims to better understand, and bring about improvements in, complex societal and environmental problems.

i2S is described in the graphic below. A more detailed description is available in the i2Insights contribution by Gabriele Bammer, Integration and Implementation Sciences (i2S) 3.0: An updated framework to foster expertise for tackling complex problems.

Integration and Implementation Insights (i2Insights) blog and toolkit brings i2S to life by highlighting tools in weekly blog posts and storing them in an indexed and accessible way. 

Both i2S and i2Insights also seek to connect and build an academic community that develops and applies those tools, especially specialists who support teams with i2S expertise.

bammer_i2S-framework_version-3_colour
i2S framework version 3.0 (Source: Gabriele Bammer). A printable version of this image is available in colour (323KB) or in black and white (486KB).

To understand how i2S operates as a discipline, it is useful to examine the closest analogy among existing disciplines, namely statistics. Like statisticians, i2S specialists contribute to, and collaborate with, teams tackling a wide range of problems in health, the environment, education, security and more. A comparison is provided in the following table and described in the i2Insights contribution by Gabriele Bammer, Three lessons from statistics for interdisciplinarians and fellow travellers:

bammer_i2s-explained_statisticans-and-i2s-specialists

In addition to the infographic for the i2S framework 3.0 shown above, three images are used to depict i2S:

  1. i2S ‘swirl’
  2. i2S ‘word cloud’
  3. the sculpture Kulla’s Ripple by Tim Spellman.

——

i2S swirl

The i2S swirl is our logo and symbolises the synergies among disparate ways of tackling complex societal and environmental problems.

 

——

i2S word cloud

The i2S word cloud contains the names of various approaches to tackling complex societal and environmental problems. The aim of i2S is to provide a conduit connecting these approaches, as a common underlying discipline which promotes cross-fertilisation. The i2Insights blog and repository draws on resources developed by all of these approaches.

It is also important to note that there are many individual and groups of researchers seeking to improve understanding of, and action on, complex real-world problems who do not identify with any of the approaches listed in the word cloud. They may be known as T-shaped researchers or knowledge brokers. They are an additional, important group that i2S seeks to connect with.

A list of various approaches that tackle complex societal and environmental problems

——

Kulla’s Ripple by Tim Spellman

The sculpture Kulla’s Ripple by Tim Spellman (2000) provides a useful metaphor for several key dimensions of i2S. The ANU Sculpture Walk brochure (https://hrc.cass.anu.edu.au/files/docs/2025/3/Sculpture-Walk-Brochure_ANU.pdf (PDF 2.1MB)), described the sculpture as follows: “The spherical and concave shapes link the two parts of the installation with their suggestion of symbiotic pairs: positive and negative, solid and void, the mould and the moulded. Spellman describes his work as the attempt to create wholeness from the dualities of past and present, the physical and the spiritual.”

From the perspective of i2S, three symbiotic pairs are important:

  • tractable and intactable problems (the latter are often called complex or wicked problems)
  • reductionist and systemic research approaches
  • knowns and unknowns.

Unlike the sculpture where both elements of the pair are reasonably equal, the symbiotic pairs relevant to i2S are not, with the right-hand element in each pair (intractable problems, systemic research approaches and dealing with unknowns) relatively underdeveloped. Indeed the rationale for i2S is to: a) improve the research community’s ability (and therefore the ability of society in general) to deal with intractable problems; b) strengthen systemic research approaches; and, c) advance understanding and management of the unknown.

Whereas the ability of research to deal with tractable problems using reductionist methods is highly developed and sophisticated, the ability of research to deal with intractable complex problems using systems-based methods is still relatively ill-formed and unwieldy. i2S aims to even out the relationship by enhancing the ability of research to deal with intractable problems.

The sculpture is located on ANU Campus on Chifley Meadow, near the Menzies Library.

A photograph of the sculpture Kulla's Ripple by Tim Spellman, as found on the ANU campus; depicting two separate mosaic blocks, one with a half-round indentation and one with a half-round insert, implying they fit into each other